The fourth and final season of “The Man in the High Castle” (2019) ended the show pretty strongly — I’d rate it an 8 out of 10 for concluding the dystopian science fiction epic just when its ambitious storytelling started getting too unwieldy.
I won’t lie to you … I loved the show, and was the sort of fan that exhorted all of my friends to watch it — but even I have to admit that there were some general narrative failures. This show tackled nothing less than multiple, detailed parallel universes — each with its own history and analogous characters. (It is an Axis Powers’ World War II victory that sets the stage for the story’s initial, “prime” universe.) That’s a lot to tackle, and “The Man in the High Castle” didn’t always follow through. (It didn’t help that there was a seeming myriad of subplots and character arcs fleshing out its prime universe alone — and that some of Season 4’s story setups seemed redundant with those of prior seasons.)
By the show’s end, there were major plot threads that were left dangling — including key questions about the show’s basic plot elements. I wouldn’t blame many longtime fans for feeling frustrated at the overall story’s insufficient exposition — and this last season’s deliberately vague, befuddling final moments.
But “The Man in the High Castle” was still simply too good to dislike. What the show does well, it tends to do very well — especially its grand, sweeping, Wagnerian science fiction world-building. I’ll bet you’ll never see another what-if-the-Nazis-won story as good as this one. With everything from its panoramic backdrops to its costuming to its incidental dialogue, “The Man in the High Castle” tackles its sprawling milieu with zeal, style and impressive detail. You can tell that it was a labor of love for the screenwriters to bring Philip K. Dick’s dangerous multiverse to the screen.
Its cast includes performers that absolutely shine — most notably Rufus Sewell as the premier American Nazi, John Smith, but also Alexa Davalos, Chelah Hordal, Joel de la Fuente and Rick Worthy. For me, Sewell often made the show; his role here seems like one he was born for.
Despite its admittedly significant flaws, Season 4 was still a great watch.